People have said for a long time that art is good for them. That is a feeling most of us recognize, and a claim that is easy to oversell. In 2019, a large public review tried to see what the evidence actually held. The evidence, as the authors gathered it, is about people making, looking at, and gathering around work that other people have made.
Daisy Fancourt and Saoirse Finn, then at the Institute of Epidemiology and Health Care at University College London, wrote What is the evidence on the role of the arts in improving health and well-being? A scoping review, published in Copenhagen by the WHO Regional Office for Europe as Health Evidence Network synthesis report 67. The report is a commissioned, internationally peer-reviewed synthesis. Its front matter is careful about ownership: "the contents are the responsibility of the authors" and "do not necessarily reflect the official policies of the Regional Office." That limit should stay attached to anything said about the findings here.
The headline, in the report's own wording, is modest and large at the same time. "Overall, the findings demonstrated that the arts can potentially impact both mental and physical health." That is a serious reason art matters in people's lives, and a serious reason to take living artists seriously. It is not a medical promise about any single work, and it is not advice about treatment.
What was reviewed
The review "used a scoping review methodology to map the global academic literature in English and Russian from January 2000 to May 2019." A scoping review, in ordinary language, is a structured map of what has been studied, not a single trial of a single intervention. The authors were gathering a field, not proving one remedy.
The scale is easier to hold if it is kept in the report's fuller count. "Over 900 publications were identified, of which there were over 200 reviews, systematic reviews, meta-analyses and meta-syntheses covering over 3000 studies, and over 700 further individual studies." The study designs ranged from uncontrolled pilots and case studies to nationally representative longitudinal cohorts and randomized controlled trials. The evidence is broad, and it is not all of one quality, which the authors will say later in plain words.
What "the arts" means in this review is also broader than a quiet hour in a gallery, and broader than music alone. The report lists five categories of engagement: performing arts, including music, dance, theatre, singing, and film; "visual arts, design and craft (e.g. crafts, design, painting, photography, sculpture and textiles)"; literature; culture, meaning "going to museums, galleries, art exhibitions, concerts, the theatre, community events, cultural festivals and fairs"; and "online, digital and electronic arts (e.g. animations, film-making and computer graphics)." Both active and receptive engagement are included. Making counts. Looking and listening count too.
Those are the review's categories of engagement, quoted as the authors wrote them. They describe ways people take part in the arts, including work made by other people's hands, voices, and judgment. They are not a claim about any particular tool, and they are not a brief for images produced without an artist.
That breadth is part of why the findings feel human rather than technical. A person singing in a group, a person at a heritage site, a person at a bench with craft materials, and a person in front of a painting are all inside the map.
What the findings feel like
The results clustered under two large headings. One is prevention and promotion: the social determinants of health, child development, health-promoting behaviours, help in preventing ill health, and support for caregiving. The other is management and treatment: mental illness, acute care, neurodevelopmental and neurological disorders, noncommunicable diseases, and end-of-life care. Those are the report's clusters, not a menu of treatments, and they should not be read as a promise that any one activity will do any one of those jobs.
At a more ordinary scale, the report finds "a large body of research showing how arts engagement can enhance multidimensional subjective well-being, including affective well-being (positive emotions in our daily lives), evaluative well-being (our life satisfaction) and eudemonic well-being (our sense of meaning, control, autonomy and purpose in our lives)." The language is technical, and the three parts are easy to recognize: daily feeling, a sense that life is going well enough, and a sense that it means something and that one has some say in it.
The activities studied include singing, group drumming, arts and crafts, dancing, and visiting cultural heritage sites. "The arts also provide a recognized way of reducing loneliness and social isolation." On prevention and the mind, "Activities such as making and listening to music, dancing, art and visiting cultural sites are all associated with stress management and prevention, including … lower daily anxiety," and "Arts engagement can also help to reduce the risk of developing mental illness such as depression in adolescence and in older age."
These are the review's syntheses. They are not a guarantee for any reader, and they are not a prescription. A person who sings, or visits a museum, or works with their hands may recognize themselves in the scenes. A person who does not feel better afterwards is not failing a test the report set.
In the conclusions, the authors write of evidence for "the potential value of the arts in contributing to core determinants of health; playing a critical role in health promotion; helping to prevent the onset of mental illness and age-related physical decline; supporting the treatment or management of mental illness, noncommunicable diseases and neurological disorders; and assisting in acute and end-of-life care." The report then turns to policy considerations for the WHO European Region. This essay stops at the evidence about people's lives. It is not a lobbying document, and it does not imply that WHO is asking anyone to do anything here.
What the authors are careful not to claim
In the discussion, the authors write that "the overall evidence base shows a robust impact of the arts on both mental and physical health." That sentence should not travel alone. They also state that "There was naturally variation in the quality of this evidence, and certain areas where findings remain to be confirmed or understood better," and that "this should not be taken to imply that the arts are a universal palliative."
Those limits are not fine print. They are part of the finding. A robust map can still be uneven. Some questions are clearer than others. Art can matter a great deal in a life and still not be a cure-all, a substitute for care, or a treatment plan. The report does not say otherwise, and neither should a reader who is moved by it.
It also does not follow that any particular painting, concert, or craft session will have a particular effect, or that buying, selling, or owning a work treats an illness. The evidence is about engagement with the arts, in the broad sense the authors used. It is not a claim about a product, a venue, or a single artist's work.
Why this is a reason to care about artists
If engagement with the arts is part of how people stay well, then living artists, craftspeople, musicians, writers, and the places that show their work are part of ordinary human health. They are not a luxury bolted on afterwards, once everything important has already been taken care of. The work in question is work people have made: one painting, one song, one pot, one performance, each the result of someone's hands, choices, and judgment.
That is a reason to take their work seriously, and a reason to keep the rooms, tools, and occasions through which people actually meet it. It is not a sales argument, and it is not a claim that attending to art will make anyone well. The more careful version is already strong enough. People sing, make, look, and gather around work that other people have made, and a large, cautious review found that this can potentially affect both mental and physical health. The authors left room for doubt in the right places. The respect can stay, and so can the doubt.
Sources
1. Fancourt D, Finn S. What is the evidence on the role of the arts in improving health and well-being? A scoping review. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2019 (Health Evidence Network synthesis report 67). Official record: https://iris.who.int/handle/10665/329834. Publication page: https://www.who.int/europe/publications/i/item/9789289054553.
Sources & further reading
More from the worktable
- The work being made now
- Looking at art, and feeling less alone
- When the format is the work
- A person set the line, and a public could see it
- The rule before the hand
- When the making stays in the work
- While the ground is still wet
- Pen plotters, rag paper, and ink quirks
- Kiln openings and edition margins
- The plotter had a hand in it
- The artist closes the lot
FOR WORKING ARTISTS
Show a piece while it is still taking shape
Post studio photographs and candid notes between states. You keep 100% copyright to your work and choose yourself when a lot finishes (88% to the artist, 12% house fee).
FOR CURIOUS COLLECTORS
Follow the studio floor from early sketches
Read how paints, papers, plates, and plotters hold their trail, or step into the room to see active works in motion. When you bid, we place a hold on your card for that amount and only charge it if you win. Card holds typically last about seven days, so a hold can lapse while a lot is still open. If you're outbid, the hold is cancelled and nothing is charged, though your bank decides how quickly it disappears from your statement.
All essays · Mediums · The journal · RSS