Skip to content
← All studio essays

FIG. 01 — STUDIO WRITING

When the format is the work

15 November 2026 · Escherbridge · Glitxz · glitch art · file formats · art history

A digital photograph looks finished the moment it appears on a screen. It is easy to treat the file underneath as a neutral wrapper, the way a frame is supposed to disappear around a painting. A format is not that kind of wrapper. What makes that fact visible is not the format acting on its own. It is an artist deciding to look at it, and to keep what she finds.

LI-MA, in its case study of Rosa Menkman's A Vernacular of File Formats, describes a file format as "an encoding system that organises data according to a particular syntax." Those organisations, the same page says, "are commonly referred to as compression algorithms." The choice of compression is influenced by intended use, whether for print or for digital distribution, by the necessary accuracy, and by the software or hardware used to render the image. Before anyone applies a style, the format already has an aesthetic of its own.

That is a dry sentence with a slightly unsettling consequence. If the encoding already has a look, then a "broken" image may not be a defect at all. It may be the format, finally left in view by a person who chose not to hide it.

One portrait, many formats

In 2010, Menkman made that argument visible with a single picture. A Vernacular of File Formats, as the same LI-MA case study describes it, is an archive from a research project on file formats, built from "intentionally glitched images, all derived from a single self-portrait, processed through various file formats." "Each glitch reveals the unique aesthetic of the data organisation inherent in these formats."

The method is almost austere, and it is hers. One face. Many encodings. She started from a self-portrait, pushed it through those formats on purpose, and kept the breaks that showed each syntax. The differences you see are not a mood applied on top of the portrait, and they are not the format making the work in her place. They are what she asked each encoding to show, and what her eye judged worth keeping. A viewer who has only ever met a file as a finished rectangle on a phone can, for a moment, see the organisation that usually stays hidden.

The work has appeared as a PDF guide to databending, as prints, and as digital displays. Menkman, LI-MA notes, "has expressed a preference for physical prints, where the texture and pixelation of the images are tangible." That preference is worth sitting with. A glitch on a backlit screen can still look like a temporary error, something a refresh might fix. On paper, the same pixelation has a surface. You can stand at a normal viewing distance and see that the break has weight, and that you are looking at a particular object she chose to make.

The output is "conceptually variable," and the archive is described as dynamic because the artist revisits and repurposes parts of the work. The piece is not a single definitive still. It is a way of looking that she can take up again, with her own hand still in the deciding.

Kept as more than one picture

A work about formats eventually had to be kept as more than one kind of object. In December 2016, according to the same case study, MOTI Museum of the Image — a collection that later became part of Museum Breda — and the Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam acquired A Vernacular of File Formats from the artist "as a 16 - 18 GB archive of files put together by the artist in collaboration with the museums."

The archive, as LI-MA lists it, includes source video and frames; a catalogue of unstable glitched files; Monglot, the glitching software; the PDF; stable printed iterations; and production documentation of prints and exhibitions. That is not a packing list for its own sake. It is part of the work's history, and it is a record of her choices. A museum that wanted a single hero image would have been asking the wrong question. The work is the set of encodings she made, the unstable files alongside the stable prints, and the means by which she made those files.

There is a quiet historical shift in that decision. For a long time, a picture in a collection was one object you could hang, or one file you could store as if it were a photograph of a hanging. Here, the public record is an archive whose size is given as 16 to 18 gigabytes, and whose contents are allowed to be mixed: sources, software, a guide, prints that hold still, and files that do not. The format is not the container around the art, and it is not the artist. It is part of the material she chose, and part of what was acquired.

Glitch as a genre

The same practice sits inside a wider conversation about glitch as a genre, not only as a studio trick. In 2011, the Institute of Network Cultures published Menkman's The Glitch Moment(um) as Network Notebooks 04, in Amsterdam. The publisher's page says the book "makes sense of recent glitch art and culture: technically, culturally, critically, aesthetically and finally as a genre."

"The glitch," that page continues, "takes on a different form in relation to noise, failure or the accident. It transitions between artifact and filter; between radical breakages and commodification processes." Menkman is described there as a Dutch visualist, theorist and curator "working with glitches, compressions, feedback and other forms of noise artifacts, aiming to contribute to the development of a discourse for glitch art and culture."

That is a short map, and it is enough. A glitch can be an accident an artist keeps, or a filter she chooses, or something that has already been smoothed into a look. The interesting part is not a romance of failure, and it is not a machine left to generate breaks on its own. It is the moment when an encoding stops pretending to be invisible, because someone with a practiced eye decided to leave it visible, and a viewer can tell the difference between a break that was kept and a file that simply failed.

Once you can see a format

Once you can see a format, it becomes harder to pretend that a digital image is weightless, or that every copy is the same picture. Two files can share a subject and still be different works, because they were organised differently, and because an artist chose one organisation rather than another. A print can hold a texture that a screen flattens. An archive can include both the stable iteration and the unstable one, and that mixture can be the point.

This is a historical change in how a picture is made and kept, and it is still unfolding. Artists who treat encoding, compression, and noise as material are working in a line that already has a public record: a 2010 vernacular built by one artist from one portrait, a 2011 notebook that named glitch as a genre, and a 2016 acquisition that kept the work as many formats rather than as a single frame.

Living artists are still finding new ways to make those encodings visible, with their own hands, choices, and judgment. The useful habit, if you care about their work, is a simple one. Look at the picture, and then ask what kind of file, print, or archive you are actually looking at. The format is already part of the work, because someone chose to leave it in view.

Sources

1. LI-MA, “A Vernacular of File Formats (2010) - Rosa Menkman.” https://li-ma.nl/article/vernacular-of-file-formats-summary/

2. Institute of Network Cultures, Rosa Menkman, The Glitch Moment(um) (Network Notebooks 04, 2011). https://networkcultures.org/blog/publication/no-04-the-glitch-momentum-rosa-menkman/

Related reading

- What is glitch art

Sources & further reading

More from the worktable

FOR WORKING ARTISTS

Show a piece while it is still taking shape

Post studio photographs and candid notes between states. You keep 100% copyright to your work and choose yourself when a lot finishes (88% to the artist, 12% house fee).

Apply as an artist →

FOR CURIOUS COLLECTORS

Follow the studio floor from early sketches

Read how paints, papers, plates, and plotters hold their trail, or step into the room to see active works in motion. When you bid, we place a hold on your card for that amount and only charge it if you win. Card holds typically last about seven days, so a hold can lapse while a lot is still open. If you're outbid, the hold is cancelled and nothing is charged, though your bank decides how quickly it disappears from your statement.

All essays · Mediums · The journal · RSS